For Sale: 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON - REW
Boost your listing
Listing featured. Your listing will be featured on REW.
View featured placement
$899,900
3 bd • 2 ba • 1100 - 1500 sf • House
58 Methodist Island
Street ViewDirections
$899,900
Get pre-approved

58 Methodist IslandTay, ON, L0K 1R0

Port McNicoll
  • 3 Bed
  • 2 Bath
  • 1100 - 1500 Sqft
  • House

About this home

A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighbors as you cruise by. The 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage has been completely gutted and transformed into a turnkey high end property. New flooring, new kitchen, new appliances, new furniture, new bathrooms and pot lights throughout. With the bonus of a Muskoka room for extra sleeping quarters or peaceful retreat. This cottage can sleep up to 10 people comfortably. The hot tub extends your days outdoors into the evenings with sounds of laughter and joy from the kids. Inside turn on Netflix and watch movies on the 75 big screen. High speed internet when working remotely is top notch. This is more than a cottage, its a lifestyle!
Listed by: Tim Hewitt, Salesperson, CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.

Home facts and features

Price details
List Price
$899,900
Get Pre-Approved
Gross Taxes for 2025
$3,669
Home facts
Bedrooms
3
Full Bathrooms
2
Property Type
House
Lot Size
77 ft x 220 ft (16962 ft²)
Depth
220.0
Frontage
77.1
Exterior Finish
Board & Batten
Heating Type
Baseboard, Electric
Community
Agent details
Primary Agent
Tim Hewitt
Primary Broker
CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
Secondary Agent
Blair Smith
Secondary Broker
CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
Listing details
Days on REW
47 Days
Property Views
28
MLS® Number
S13227130
Source
Toronto Real Estate Board
Is this your listing? Help it to stand out.

Mortgage Calculator

Estimated Payments
Purchase Price
Mortgage Total
Down Payment
Amortization
25 Years
Interest Rate
3.99%

Connect with our mortgage partner

REW Money

REW Money

REW Money

Connect with a mortgage expert

Connect to a mortgage specialist

REW Money
REW Money

They will connect with you to understand where you are in your journey and how they can best guide you.

  • %
Name*
Email*
Phone*
Purchase City*
What best describes your current situation?
Loan Details
Amortization
Years
Mortgage Amount
Down Payment

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

By proceeding, you consent to receive communications using the methods provided, from REW.ca and our partners about your inquiry and other home-related matters to assist you in your search, but not as a condition of any purchase.

The displayed rates are provided as guidance only, are not guaranteed, or are to be considered an approval of credit. Approval will be based solely on your personal situation. You are encouraged to speak with a Mortgage Professional for the most accurate information and to determine your eligibility.

The displayed rates are provided as guidance only, are not guaranteed, or are to be considered an approval of credit. Approval will be based solely on your personal situation. You are encouraged to speak with a Mortgage Professional for the most accurate information and to determine your eligibility.

Property Insights

Tay Shores Public School
  • Public
  • JK - 8
St Antoine Daniel Catholic School
  • Catholic
  • JK - 8
School catchments and distances are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrolment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.Report Incorrect Info
Report Incorrect Info
Full Name*
Email*
Select School
Reason

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

By proceeding, you consent to receive communications using the methods provided, from REW.ca and our partners about your inquiry and other home-related matters to assist you in your search, but not as a condition of any purchase.
Thank You!
We really appreciate your help improving our home search experience. Our team will look into this issue as soon as possible.
Close

Cities near Port McNicoll

Neighborhoods near Port McNicoll

Listing data is subject to copyright, disclaimer, and additional requirements from the data provider. See our Terms of Use for terms applicable to this listing. Listing data was last updated on 2026-07-18.
Call Agent
Salesperson
Tim Hewitt
Phone:
(705) 791-9987
Office:
705-721-9111
Salesperson
Blair Smith
Phone:
(705) 623-4005
Office:
705-721-9111
Share this Property
Text Message
Share this Property
Recipient Email Address*
Your Name
Your Email Address*

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

By proceeding, you consent to receive communications using the methods provided, from REW.ca and our partners about your inquiry and other home-related matters to assist you in your search, but not as a condition of any purchase.