“Stress Test Makes Housing Less Affordable,” Mortgage Brokerage Tells Feds

Dominion Lending Centres fights back against strict new qualification rules with submission to federal finance committee, which argues brief in recent hearing

By
REW.ca
February 3, 2017






Dan Albas Conservative MP federal finance committee
Dan Albas, Conservative MP for Central Okanagan-Similkameen-Nicola, spoke out against the new mortgage "stress test" rules at the federal finance committee hearing January 30, 2017

In an impassioned submission to the federal Standing Committee on Finance, the country’s largest mortgage brokerage has hit back against strict new mortgage qualification rules, arguing that they are putting home ownership out of reach for many thousands of first-time and lower-income buyers.

Gary Mauris, president and CEO of Dominion Lending Centres (DLC), said in a press release, “While we understand and agree with the government’s desire to protect consumers, DLC fundamentally disagrees with the proposed approaches to do so, as it will make housing less affordable for the middle class. Our submission outlines several ways to encourage affordability and if the government chooses to work with industry, their proposals can be positively amended to ensure that Canadians have the best chance of achieving their home-ownership dreams.”

Mauris made the DLC’s submission ahead of the January 30 federal finance committee hearing, at which it was discussed by MPs, Bank of Canada representatives and Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions representatives.

The brokerage wrote in the brief: “All new mortgages [with a down payment of less than 20 per cent] now need to qualify at the greater of either the Bank of Canada posted rate (4.64 per cent) or the contract rate. The net effect on first-time home buyers is that their purchasing power has been reduced by upwards of 20 per cent, which has significant impacts on many marginal buyers. Not only does the stress test reduce purchasing power, it makes housing less, rather than more affordable.”

The submission included two case studies of would-be buyers whose plans for home ownership were hindered by the introduction of the stress test.

These examples were echoed during the committee hearing, at which Dan Albas, Conservative MP for Central Okanagan-Similkameen-Nicola, said that many of his constituents were feeling the negative impact from the policy.

“I’ve had people from around my riding, especially young people, who have felt that they were on a good path towards home ownership and, because of these rule changes, that’s been pushed back.

“Most of us would agree that home ownership has served Canadians quite well, and people can store away equity over the long term. This policy is preventing young people from having the benefits of home ownership enjoyed by 69 per cent of Canadians.

“There is not one Canadian real estate market, there are many smaller and larger markets, and this policy has been described as applying a sledgehammer to a very specific problem [lack of affordability in markets such as Vancouver and Toronto].”

Sylvain Leduc of the Bank of Canada replied that it was known that the policy would “reduce demand at the margin” but that total consumer debt was a problem in many regions across the country, and that the stress test was designed to ensure all Canadians were not taking on more debt that they could pay off.

Albas replied, “Spinning this policy as helping people by not letting them get into debt – that’s not how those people feel.”

DLC’s submission concluded, “The real culprit to lack of affordability is supply. To make housing more affordable without adding supply means housing prices must fall, which has a net-negative effect on the financial security of Canadians. At the same time, measures to make mortgages more difficult to obtain result in reduced housing affordability. By making housing less affordable and reducing demand (impacting home values), we are unintentionally widening the wealth gap for middle-class Canadians.

“We would strongly urge government to focus its affordability efforts with a robust strategy that involves city planners, developers and municipal and provincial governments looking at innovative ways to expediently increase the housing stock, both for home ownership and for rental.”


Joannah Connolly is the editor and content manager of REW.ca and Real Estate Weekly newspaper, and editor-in-chief of Western Investor and West Coast Condominium. She also moonlights as the host of the Real Estate Therapist call-in show on Roundhouse Radio 98.3FM every Saturday, 9-10am. A dual Canadian-British citizen, Joannah has 20 years of media experience in Vancouver and London, with a background in construction, architecture and business media. Like many of the residents of her newly adopted town, Joannah has a decidedly unhealthy passion for Vancouver real estate and is often to be found scouring property listings well above her pay grade.
© Copyright 2017

Comments

REW.ca welcomes your opinions and comments. We do not allow personal attacks, offensive language, unsubstantiated allegations or self-promotional content, including promotional website links. We reserve the right to unpublish comments, to edit them for length, style, legality and taste, and to reproduce them in print or online. For further information, please contact the editor or publisher, or see our Terms and Conditions.

comments powered by Disqus

Email to a Friend

Close

Get the REW.ca Newsletter
Most Popular
Start Your Real Estate Search with REW.ca

REW.ca is your best tool for real estate search. You'll find both MLS® homes and new developments for sale. MLS® listing search covers the real estate boards of Greater Vancouver, the Fraser Valley, Chilliwack, Vancouver Island, and Whistler. Sign up for free property alerts and read BC real estate news.

REW.ca is the online arm of the largest real estate market newspaper in the Lower Mainland: Real Estate Weekly.

The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.