Collateral Damage: Unfortunate Tales of Foreign Buyer Tax Fallout

Since August 2, there has been a stream of reports of undeserving people getting hit by crossfire from the new foreign buyer tax. Here’s a look at some of the sorriest stories so far

August 18, 2016

Stressed home buyers

August 2 saw the implementation of the new 15 per cent increase in Property Transfer Tax for overseas buyers of Greater Vancouver real estate, which outraged the real estate industry and much of the wider public by being applied to existing purchase contracts. Since then, there has been a range of media articles about those caught unexpectedly in the fallout of the new tax.

Here’s a selection of some of the biggest – and sorriest – stories.

Real Estate Deals Collapse as Foreign Buyer Tax Takes Effect –

Immediately after the August 2 implementation of the 15 per cent overseas buyer tax, the real estate industry was up in arms about the previous rules not being grandfathered for purchases agreed before August 2 but closing after that date. Deals started to collapse, although at that early stage there were few concrete examples to get hold of.

However, lawyer Richard Bell of Bell Alliance has since told of an unnamed 80-year-old Vancouver woman client of his, whose home sale to an overseas buyer has fallen through because of the new tax. Bell said that his client had to walk away from her own onward home purchase, losing her $100,000 deposit in the process – but that the deposit forfeited by her own buyers has covered this loss. He added that the collapse of the sale has caused enormous stress to his client, who is now worried about being able to sell her home again for as good a price.

Bell also told of an unnamed local construction company that is recruiting a new VP from the US, who had been planning to buy a Vancouver home after taking the job. However, the recruit, who is already living in Vancouver and has a work permit and a family in the city, is now renegotiating his salary with the company as his housing costs have just increased dramatically.

Foreign Buyer Tax to Cost Iranian Immigrant Thousands on First Home –

The new tax blindsided a Vancouver man waiting for his permanent resident status to be processed, according to this August 3 story by the CBC.

Iranian-born Hamed Ahmadi, who has been living and working in Vancouver for four years, and is a BC Hydro engineer with a work permit, says he's facing thousands in unexpected costs on the $360,000 home he is buying in Coquitlam. As his permanent residency visa is not quite processed, he has suddenly become liable for an extra $54,000 tax on the property – unless he walks away from his hard-saved $18,000 deposit.

“Any way I go, I lose,” said Ahmadi.

Coquitlam Family’s Home Sale Jeopardized Because of Foreign Buyers’ Tax – Canadian Press

A local couple are on tenterhooks as they wait to see if their home sale, made earlier this year but due to close in September, will fall through as their overseas buyers may back out because of the new tax, according to this Canadian Press story on August 16.

Heather Nyberg and Dan Zimmerman are relying on the sale of the property to complete their own purchase of a nearby duplex – otherwise they will have to walk away and lose the $80,000 deposit that they put down on the home.

University Grad Faces $84K Foreign Buyers Tax on Langley Townhome –

Also published August 16, perhaps the sorriest tale of overseas buyer tax fallout could be this CBC story about a 29-year-old woman who graduated last year from the University of Saskatchewan and then moved to Burnaby to continue her life in Canada.

Hoping to put down roots, Jing Li said that she borrowed from her parents in China a 10 per cent deposit to buy a $560,000 Langley townhome. She said her parents in turn borrowed money from friends and family. But 12 days after Jing signed the contract, the new tax was implemented, adding $84,000 to the home's cost, something Jing said she can't possibly afford. But if she backs out of the deal, she will lose her deposit of about $56,000.

"Now, I can't go forward and also can't go back," she told CBC, adding that her mother cried when Jing called her parents in China to tell them. She said that she feels guilty for trying to make a life in Canada, because if she had not done so, “this disaster would not happen to my family.”

Joannah Connolly is editorial director of Glacier Real Estate, Glacier Media's real estate division. Joannah writes and curates real estate news for Glacier Media's local newspaper websites, including the Vancouver Courier, North Shore News, Burnaby Now, Tri-City News and others. She also oversees editorial content in Real Estate Weekly Homes, West Coast Condo, Western Investor and Glacier's special real estate publications. A dual Canadian-British citizen, Joannah has 22 years of journalism and editing experience in Vancouver and London, with a background in construction, architecture, healthcare and business media. Joannah has appeared on major local TV outlets as a real estate commentator, has moderated and spoken on various industry panels, and spent two years hosting the Real Estate Therapist radio show on Roundhouse Radio.
© Copyright 2018

Comments welcomes your opinions and comments. We do not allow personal attacks, offensive language, unsubstantiated allegations or self-promotional content, including promotional website links. We reserve the right to unpublish comments, to edit them for length, style, legality and taste, and to reproduce them in print or online. For further information, please contact the editor or publisher, or see our Terms and Conditions.

comments powered by Disqus

Email to a Friend