Cities “Can Solve Affordability by Building Housing”

October 24, 2017

Relatively affordable Tokyo is held up as an example of the benefits of densification

Other global cities having been “building their way to affordability for decades,” asserts Seattle research group

As Vancouver and, to a slightly lesser extent, Toronto grapple with housing affordability issues, a recent report out of Seattle asserts that many other global cities have been “building their way to affordability for decades.”

The report from Seattle research group The Sightline Institute asserts that it is a myth that a city cannot build its way out of an affordability crisis.

Report author Alan Durning, executive director of Sightline, writes, “What if you can build your way to affordable housing? What if, in fact, building is the only path to affordable housing? What if cities around the world have been building their way to affordability for decades? You can. It is. And they have.”

Durning told Vancouver’s News 1130, “While housing prices in Vancouver, as in my home city of Seattle, have been going through the roof, cities around the world have been keeping housing prices flat or rising very slowly by building lots and lots of housing.”

In his report, Durning examines the successes of a number of global cities including sprawling Houston, high-density Tokyo, pro-development Chicago, gently dense Montreal and state-supported Vienna, where extensive housing supply has kept prices flat.

Durning concedes that the Vienna model of “massive public spending and massive public control” might not work in North America, as it relies on a long history of “public-sector involvement in housing plus entrenched institutions and national laws that are beyond the pale of North American politics” and points out that comparable efforts to control housing in San Francisco have failed.

He adds, “A different, hybrid model is called for … one that harnesses the private sector to public ends. Which is not to say lessons from Vienna are not transferable. They are. Where large blocks of public land are available, for example, [they could be developed] through design competitions among developers.”

Durning extrapolates lessons from each city examined. “Houston… can be [a] model for how easy it ought to be to get permits to build homes… Tokyo, meanwhile, reminds us that placing control over development at senior levels of government, and making development of urban property a right of its owner, helps to elevate the broad public interest in abundant housing choices over parochial opposition to change. Chicago teaches that a pro-housing political orientation can provide abundant housing even under conventional zoning in a deep blue city, while Montreal offers… a model of a cityscape no longer of single-family homes but of three-story rowhouses, walk-up apartments, and condominiums on quiet, tree-lined streets close to transit and neighborhood centers.”

Durning concludes, “To have affordable housing, you have to build homes in great abundance, and without that, other affordability strategies such as rent control and inclusionary zoning can be fruitless or counterproductive, as in San Francisco. Building plenty of housing is not just one way to affordability, it is the only way – the foundation on which other affordability solutions, measures against displacement, and programs for inclusion rest.”

Joannah Connolly has been editor and content manager of since May 2014. Joannah has appeared on major local TV outlets as a real estate commentator, and has moderated and spoken on several industry panels. During this time, she also spent two years hosting the Real Estate Therapist radio show on Roundhouse Radio 98.3FM. A dual Canadian-British citizen, Joannah has 20 years of journalism experience in Vancouver and London, with a prior background in construction, architecture and business media.
© Copyright 2017

Comments welcomes your opinions and comments. We do not allow personal attacks, offensive language, unsubstantiated allegations or self-promotional content, including promotional website links. We reserve the right to unpublish comments, to edit them for length, style, legality and taste, and to reproduce them in print or online. For further information, please contact the editor or publisher, or see our Terms and Conditions.

comments powered by Disqus

Email to a Friend